23 Consignment Shops in ILLINOIS (Cheap, Durable, & Luxury)

Consignment shops are helpful for both customers that don’t want to buy new expensive items and customers that don’t want to throw their old items away.

They rent out spaces for people to resell their old items, and when someone buys them, the consignment store pays the owner a percentage.

If you want to declutter your home and make some good money, you can consider putting your items up at a consignment shop.

These shops usually have high-quality products, which makes them a good choice for cheap furniture or tools.

Don’t worry too much about locating a consignment shop near you because this article lists some great ones around Illinois that you can visit.

And by the way, you may also want to check out the best Boutiques in Illinois.

Consignment Shops in Springfield, Illinois

1. The Furniture Den (Family-Owned & 30+ Years)

The Furniture Den is a family-owned and operated consignment store that has been selling used furniture and home decor to customers in Springfield for over thirty years.

Founded by an accountant, this business aims to make furnishing and decorating your house more sustainable.

The Furniture Den has vintage and antique furniture in unique designs, all available at pocket-friendly prices.

If you’re moving into a new place soon or want to redecorate your place and you’re planning on a vintage vibe, you can find what you need at The Furniture Den.

You can also resell any used vintage or antique furniture from your home or a collection and get a good bargain at the Furniture Den.

To sell your consignment, the furniture must be in good condition with no visible tears, scratches, or dents that may discourage buyers from purchasing it.

Address: 2631 Ridge Ave, Springfield, IL 62702

2. Goodwill Industries (Land of Lincoln) (Non-Profit & Charitable Initiatives)

Goodwill Industries is a global network of non-profit organizations. Land of Lincoln is one of their agencies with numerous charitable projects and initiatives across over thirty counties in Illinois.

They organize various outreaches to contribute positively to the community, including career development events, vocational programs, veteran employment training, and youth services.

As part of its charity initiatives, Land of Lincoln operates a consignment store that accepts used items that are in good condition from donors across the country.

These products are refurbished and put up for sale at any of their retail locations, where the proceeds ultimately go back into any of their charitable causes.

Land of Lincoln accepts various used items, including fairly used clothes, housewares, radios, computers, televisions, and other valuable electronics and furniture.

They also recover and refurbish many products that are still in excellent condition but were thrown away through their community cleaning initiative.

Address: 2001 Wabash Ave, Springfield, IL 62704

3. Second Time Around (Women-Owned & Luxury Clothing)

Second Time Around is a women-owned consignment boutique specializing in reselling luxury women’s clothing.

The locally-owned and operated business initially started as a side project and has now grown into one of the most successful consignment stores in the area.

They have a large selection of branded women’s wear in the best conditions, available at prices much lower than their retail value.

Second Time Around is constantly accepting gently-used luxury women’s clothing in return for cash or store credits, making them an excellent option for disposing of used items.

While there’s no need to fix appointments, you’ll need to wait while they check your products to ensure they’re in the best condition.

The staff is polite and friendly at the Second Time Around, so they’ll gladly walk you through buying or selling a consignment.

Address: 2440 Denver Dr, Springfield, IL 62702

4. Clothes Mentor (Specializing in Women’s Wear)

Clothes Mentor is a consignment store specializing in reselling women’s clothes, shoes, and accessories.

They accept gently-used clothes from popular brands like Burberry, Cole Haan, Calvin Klein, Lululemon, and Michael Kors in sizes zero to twenty-six.

If they’re wearable, you can also sell your shoes and accessories and immediately receive cash at any Clothes Mentor store.

Once you’ve packaged your consignment and ensured they have no defects, you can visit a Clothes Mentor store, and their computerized system will ensure you’re out with your cash in no time.

If you’re shopping for quality clothes at affordable prices, you can also consider browsing the inventory at Clothes Mentor.

They have a large selection of branded clothes that sell for up to 70% off their regular retail value, making them a great option to shop and save money.

Address: 2329 W Monroe St, Springfield, IL 62704

5. Plato’s Closet (Buy & Sell Teen/Young Adult)

Plato’s Closet is a consignment store that buys fairly used clothes, accessories, and shoes in excellent condition and resells them at affordable prices.

With only 15% of clothes recycled worldwide, Plato’s Closet encourages sustainable living and reduces fashion wastage.

They accept any teenager or young adult clothes or accessories with no visible stains, tears, or other defects.

Once you have items that meet the requirements, you can visit any Plato’s Closet store during open hours and sell your items for immediate payment.

While Plato’s Closet accepts most clothes and accessories in good condition, they look for new styles and trends, including popular brands.

You can find refurbished items from different popular brands for sale at Plato’s Closet at 50% to 70% off regular retail prices.

Address: 2333 W Monroe St, Springfield, IL 62704

Also see our article on Pawn Shops in Illinois.

Consignment Shops in Peoria, Illinois

1. Replay Consignment Store (Locally-Owned & Kids’ Clothes)

Replay Consignment Store is a locally-owned and operated business that buys and sells reasonably used kid’s clothes.

They have a large selection of high-quality clothes for kids of all ages and sizes and are available at affordable prices.

You can also browse their $1 section for amazing and durable kids’ wear that you can get for a dollar, so you can do your shopping without breaking the bank.

Their store is conducive and neat, with a trendy rustic interior design and a large selection of beautiful clothes you can shop from.

The employees at the store are well-trained, friendly, and knowledgeable about all the shop’s items so that they can answer your questions adequately.

You can also sell your used kids’ clothes at the Replay Consignment store; however, drop-offs require an appointment.

Address: 121 E Lake Ave c, Peoria, IL 61614

2. Fashionably Late (Gently-Used Luxury Fashion)

Fashionably Late is a consignment shop specializing in reselling gently-used luxury clothes and fashion items from the latest trends.

They have a large selection of high-quality clothes in excellent condition, and you may even find some popular fashion brands in their inventory.

Their store is neat and well-arranged to allow customers to get a good look at luxury clothes available at affordable prices.

Fashionably Late is a huge money saver for people who want to dress stylishly without breaking the bank, as they regularly have some of the best quality items.

If you have any used clothes or clothing accessories that are trendy and in good condition, consider dry cleaning before dropping them off at Fashionably Late.

While they offer reasonable rates for consignments, drop-offs are strictly by appointment, so you must call or visit the store to set a later appointment.

Address: 5832 Knoxville Ave, Peoria, IL 61614

3. Two Sisters and a Warehouse (Family-Owned Thrift & Consignment)

Two Sisters and a Warehouse is a family-owned thrift and consignment business that offers a large selection of used and vintage items, furniture, and home decor.

The locally-owned business was established in 2016 and has since worked hard to provide customers with a large selection of quality used household items.

You can visit their consignment shop, a large store with over a hundred unique booths showcasing different products available at excellent prices.

The business also has a cafe inside the consignment store called Donna Jean’s Cafe, where you can enjoy delicious homecooked meals from Tuesday to Saturday.

If you’re in the market for affordable and elegant furniture or home decor that’s still in excellent condition, consider visiting the warehouse to browse their listings.

The owners prioritize effective customer service and consistently receive new items from their loyal vendors and donors.

Address: 121 E Lake Ave, Peoria, IL 61614

4. Sweet Caroline’s Possibilities (Family-Owned & Handmade Crafts)

Sweet Caroline’s Possibilities is a family-owned consignment store that sells handmade crafts from various repurposed items.

This locally-owned business features various items, including toys, books, clothes, jewelry, home decor, furniture, electronics, and household utensils.

These items are expertly sourced by well-trained employees and refurbished to ensure they’re in good condition and durable enough to last.

If you love handmade or homely items, then you can browse Sweet Caroline’s catalog of products available at pocket-friendly prices.

Their stores are conducive and intricately designed, allowing you to browse their products comfortably while retaining the brand’s creativity.

You’re also guaranteed excellent customer service from their friendly and knowledgeable staff.

The store is open to customers between 11 am and 6 pm from Tuesdays to Fridays and between 11 am and 5 pm on Saturdays.

Address: 4806 N Prospect Rd, Peoria Heights, IL 61616

Also see our article on Bike Shops in Illinois.

Consignment Shops in Effingham, Illinois

1. Goodwill Industries (Land of Lincoln) (Charitable Programs & Donation Center)

Goodwill Industries International is a global network of over 150 charitable agencies promoting change in their communities.

Land of Lincoln is their Illinois branch and regularly organizes events and programs to help marginalized demographics, particularly people with disabilities, veterans, and kids.

Some of their programs include career development workshops, vocational skills training, community day events, community cleanups, youth programs, and veteran employment.

As part of their business, they operate a consignment store that collects donations of used items in great condition and refurbishes them for sale at their retail locations.

You must ensure that your donations are in working condition, then you can drop them off at any of Land of Lincoln’s locations.

They have various items, including gently-used clothes and accessories, electronics, household appliances, furniture, and house decorations.

You can also shop at any of their retail locations and enjoy great products at incredible prices, knowing that all sale proceeds go back to charity.

Address: 1004 N Keller Dr, Effingham, IL 62401

2. Kathy’s Resale Shop (Locally-Owned & Various Items)

Kathy’s Resale Shop is a locally-owned and operated consignment store that buys and resells various used items, including clothes, accessories, and household items.

They have a large assortment of high-quality used items that you can get at excellent prices, and there’s always something new.

Their store is a large and conducive space, and the employees are friendly and eager to answer any questions or concerns.

If you have used items of your own and want to make some money, check to ensure they’re in good condition and bring them to Kathy’s Resale Shop.

Once their staff checks the products and confirms it’s in good condition, you’ll immediately be paid a reasonable price for the item’s value.

Kathy’s Resale Shop is open to customers from 9 am to 5 pm from Mondays to Fridays and from 9 am to 4 pm on Saturdays.

Address: 1901 S 4th St, Effingham, IL 62401

3. Silk Purse Thrift Store (Not-For-Profit & Donations)

Silk Purse is a not-for-profit consignment store that was initially a source of raising funds for the Family Life Center, a non-profit organization focusing on family or pregnancy-related issues.

Established in 2001, Silk Purse has grown to be a major thrift store with a large selection of used items at excellent prices.

The Silk Purse has a vast inventory of used products in excellent condition, including electronics, furniture, books, toys, household appliances, and clothes.

Unlike regular consignment stores that pay cash for your items, The Silk Purse collects free donations from concerned donors and refurbishes them for sale.

The refurbished items are sold at low prices to help low-income families and individuals enjoy quality products, and the proceeds from sales go back into various charitable causes.

If you’re looking to shop extensively without breaking the bank, this location is excellent.

Address: 908 W Fayette Ave, Effingham, IL 62401

4. Nearly New Fashions Inc. (Wide Range of Fashion Items)

Nearly New Fashions is a locally-owned and operated consignment store that specializes in buying and reselling clothes that are in good condition.

They accept different types of used items from popular and unpopular brands, including shoes, jeans, dresses, and clothing accessories.

To sell your used items, ensure they’re in the best condition with no stains or tears, and visit Nearly New Fashions with a valid ID to get paid.

Based on customer reviews, you need to make an appointment at the store before you bring in any consignments for sale.

However, the store is available for customers shopping for used clothes to walk in anytime and enjoy their fantastic prices.

Their store is beautiful but jammed full with different stylish used clothes, showing they constantly receive new consignments.

Address: 802 S Willow St, Effingham, IL 62401

Also see our article on Yarn Shops in Illinois.

Consignment Shops in Geneva, Illinois

1. The Exchange of Geneva (Upscale, Various Clothes & Shoes)

The Exchange of Geneva is a locally-owned and operated consignment store that buys and resells all types of clothes and shoes, from athletic to luxury wear.

They have a large selection of durable used items, including products from popular brands that are available at a fraction of their retail value.

This makes The Exchange of Geneva an excellent option if you want to shop without spending a lot of money.

You can also make some quick cash by selling used items still in good condition at The Exchange, Geneva.

They accept all types of clothes and clothing accessories and children’s books, shoes, bags, toys, and games.

To ensure they accept your items and you get paid, ensure you clean them properly and they’re in an almost new or functional condition, without defects like tears, stains, or odors.

Address: 219 W State St, Geneva, IL 60134

2. Always in Style (Women’s Boutique)

Always in Style is an upscale women’s consignment boutique that offers luxury brand items to customers at much lower prices.

This locally-owned business was created to allow women to dress in the latest fashion trends and luxury brands without breaking the bank.

They sort through hundreds of items from their consignors and pick only those that are of excellent quality and in the best condition.

You can find clothes, shoes, jewelry, and handbags from various popular luxury brands, including Louis Vuitton, Lululemon, White House Black Market, and Sanctuary.

Always in Style Boutique constantly receives new items from hundreds of consignors, and there’s always something new to buy each day.

You can also make extra money by searching your wardrobe for popular branded items you don’t wear anymore.

Address: 500 S 3rd St Suite 111, Geneva, IL 60134

3. Anew Consignment Shop (Upscale Women’s Boutique)

Anew Consignment Shop is an upscale women’s consignment boutique that provides luxury clothes to women and teenagers on a budget.

They have many fashionable used shoes, bags, jewelry, and clothes from popular luxury brands.

With a reliable network of consigners, Anew receives new functional fashion items regularly, and there’s always something for you at their store.

If you have used fashion items that are taking up space in your home, consider going to Anew, where you can make up to 40% of the item’s sale price.

While walk-ins are allowed, it’s best to call the store before dropping off any consignments, as the store may not accept items for a while.

Once you fix a schedule, ensure the items aren’t more than fifteen at a time and check them thoroughly to ensure no defects.

Address: 27 W State St # A, Geneva, IL 60134

4. Stitch Switch (Male Consignment Boutique)

Stitch Switch is a locally-owned and operated male consignment boutique that provides a sustainable way for men to follow fashion trends and wear luxury brands.

They receive hundreds of gently-used luxury cloth items from their consignors, refurbish them, then sell them at sixty to eighty percent below their retail value.

Their inventory is constantly updated because they receive consignments frequently, so there’s always a new item in the shop that may interest you.

However, they have a solid base of loyal customers who are always looking for great deals, so it’s best to subscribe to their mailing list and get regular updates.

You can sell your used items at Stitch Switch; however, ensure they’re in wearable condition, not more than thirty items at a time.

They accept luxury and branded fashion items and pay sixty to eighty percent of the asking price.

Address: 310 Campbell St, Geneva, IL 60134

Also see our article on Book Stores in Illinois.

Consignment Shops in Morton, Illinois

1. Just for Looks (Upscale, Furniture & Decor)

Just For Looks is a locally-owned and operated upscale consignment store specializing in reselling used furniture, home decor, and other appliances.

They have many elegant home furniture, including living room accessories, home decorations, ornaments, centerpieces, and decorative throw pillows.

With a network of over 1,000 consignors, Just For Looks constantly receives new items, and you can expect an amazing find each time.

If you’re shopping for furniture and want a premium selection without breaking the bank, consider some of Just for Looks’ products, selling at much lower than their retail value.

While they take precautions to ensure that they only accept products in the best condition, Just For Looks doesn’t offer warranties or refunds, so ensure you check each item carefully before buying.

If you have used furniture, you can also consider selling to them as a consigner.

Address: 110 W Adams, Morton, IL 61550

2. Upscale Resale (Non-Profit & Charitable Initiatives)

Upscale Resale is a consignment store operated as a fund-raising initiative for We Care Inc, a non-profit organization that organizes various charitable programs.

They aim to create a more sustainable and connected community through initiatives like their elderly transport, family support, and feed the public programs.

Volunteers operate the store entirely, and they welcome donations from all members of the public.

Unlike typical consignment stores, you don’t get paid for donating your items at Upscale Resale, as the proceeds go to their various charity projects.

However, they have a fantastic selection of books, clothes, shoes, furniture, and home decorations in excellent condition, which you can get at affordable prices.

You can visit their shop between 10 am and 4 pm from Mondays to Fridays and between 10 am and 3 pm on Saturdays.

Address: 109 S Main St, Morton, IL 61550

Also see our article on Outdoor Activities in Illinois.

Consignment Shops in Champaign, Illinois

1. Karen’s Kloset (Luxury Women’s Items)

Karen’s Kloset was established in 1991 by Karen Boudreau, who did a lot of shopping and quickly realized she couldn’t afford some of the fashion items she wanted.

She later discovered consignment stores and wanted to create a resale shop that retained a boutique atmosphere, so Karen’s Kloset was born.

It’s a locally-owned upscale boutique specializing in reselling gently-used luxury items at much lower prices than their retail value.

The Karen’s Kloset store has an upscale boutique feel, with luxurious decor and friendly staff happy to review their inventory with you.

You can always make some money by dropping off any old designer clothes, shoes, or accessories at Karen’s Kloset as long as they’re in season and don’t have any defects.

Suppose you’d like to make cash off your consignments or drop off more than thirty items, then you need to make an appointment.

Address: 231 S Mattis Ave, Champaign, IL 61821

2. Classic Home Consignment (Large Store & Quality Furniture)

Classic Home Consignment has been in the consignment business for over a decade, providing customers with a diverse set of quality used products.

They have a large 3,200 sq feet store that constantly receives gently-used household items from their base of consigners, meaning there are always new arrivals.

Their inventory includes a large selection of quality furniture and home decor in excellent condition.

Shopping for new furniture can be costly, and Classic Home Consignment helps you save money by offering quality furniture at pocket-friendly prices.

They aim for full customer satisfaction, and all their employees provide excellent customer service.

Once you visit their store, someone will guide you through their products to help you find what suits your needs.

You can also sell your old furniture and home decor at Classic Home Consignments for up to 50% of its sale price.

Address: 1912 Round Barn Rd, Champaign, IL 61821

3. Plato’s Closet (Sustainable Fashion)

Plato’s Closet is an excellent location to buy high-quality refurbished cloth items, including from some popular named brands.

The consignment store is dedicated to sustainable fashion, and they accept and repurpose different types of clothes, shoes, and accessories in good condition.

Then, they dry clean them and sell them at affordable prices, usually up to 50% off regular retail prices.

If you have any old clothes in good condition cluttering your wardrobe, you can clean them and walk into Plato’s Closet to sell them for an instant payout.

While they usually accept all clothes, Plato’s Closet has a bias for current trends, and you can check their website for more information on the items they like.

Selling your clothes is easy, and all you need is a valid ID; once the staff reviews the item and finds it satisfactory, you instantly get paid.

Address: 41 E Marketview Dr, Champaign, IL 61820

4. Furniture Lounge (Modern & Mid-Century Furniture)

Furniture Lounge is a locally-owned and operated consignment shop specializing in buying and reselling used modern and mid-century furniture.

The veteran and woman-owned business also accept and resells vintage clothes that are still wearable.

If you have old furniture in your basement or garage, consider cleaning it up and heading to Furniture Lounge to resell it for a great price.

Many customers have sold their used items at Furniture Lounge, and they all testify that the process is fair, straightforward, and rewarding.

If you’re moving into a new place or need new furniture at your old place, Furniture Lounge is a great option instead of breaking the bank at a furniture company.

They have unique items at affordable prices, and the Furniture Lounge employees will gladly offer some recommendations and help you make the best buy.

Address: 11 E University Ave, Champaign, IL 61820

If you liked this article, you may also like to read about the best Boutiques, Flower Shops, and Bike Shops in Illinois.

Looking beyond Illinois? Check out our article on the best Consignment Shops in Texas.